
THE MF M.D.P.
Since we’re still in the early phases of getting to know each other, I thought now would be a good time to break out my personal All-Browns Team. A lot of people think these little exercises are pointless or ridiculous (fortunately, 99% of those people aren’t in the demographic I’m targeting…I’m assuming you’re a football fan). Like Rob Gordon from “High Fidelity,” I’ve always enjoyed the combination of sports banter and nostalgia that comes with making Top-Whatever lists. Plus, it’s a good way to set the tone for, or parameters of, the discussion going forward. In music, for example, it just helps us understand each other better if I know whether you’re a Stones or Beatles person. Likewise in football; you’re probably coming from a different place if you wear a Joe Thomas jersey than if you wear a throwback Sipe, or a Josh Cribbs for that matter. So, you may be wondering, whose jersey do I wear?
Well, actually… nobody’s, as it turns out. I’m still looking for that dare to be great situation. But I do have “my guys”- those players whom I have identified as great players, great Browns, or just guys I happen to love watching play football. PLEASE NOTE: I am only choosing from among players I have seen play (and not on old reels on the NFL Network. I have to have seen them play a game in my lifetime). Obviously, Jim Brown is the greatest player in Browns and probably NFL history. Conceded. But under the parameters of this analysis, he doesn’t qualify. I debated whether any affiliation with the Ravens should also be grounds for elimination, ultimately deciding against such a constraint. But just barely.
My personal All-Time Browns team is coached by Marty Schottenheimer, who believed unfailingly in the time-tested formula of a physically dominant defense and power running game. Even went 14-2 with the Chargers on that formula during the new “pass-first” era. Of course, he was promptly fired for the achievement (and replaced with Norv Turner, of all people!). Just a damn good ball coach. Be it not forgotten: There’s a gleam, men. There’s a gleam.
OFFENSE
QB: BERNIE KOSAR
Most Browns fans of my vintage have a similar affection for an awkward, sidearm sling followed by a fluttery duck-esque lob that somehow falls softly and perfectly into the hands of the intended receiver, over and over again. Survived on brains, moxy, and uncanny touch. To this day it chaps my hide that my buddy Tim has a picture with him and I don’t.
RB: EARNEST BYNER
FB: KEVIN MACK
Despite his association with certain unfortunate events, Byner was an outstanding all-around back with plus power. As the surname indicates, Mack was something you either got out of the way of or it destroyed you. Both went for more than 1,000 yards in ’85, only the third pair of teammates to accomplish the feat in NFL history. If not for Roger Craig and Tom Rathman, they might be known as the best backfield 1-2 punch of the 1980’s.
WR: WEBSTER SLAUGHTER, REGGIE LANGHORNE
Sensing a theme? Look, we’re Browns fans. If I were a Giants or Cowboys or Steelers or Dolphins fan, I might have a sprinkling of guys from various eras. As it stands, we in the Pound haven’t had a lot of great players to follow the past couple of decades. There’s not a lot of competition here because the Browns of the mid-to-late 80’s are the only decent team the franchise has seen during my football cognizance, so they are going to be well-represented here. Regardless, these two could have produced in any era. Kevin Johnson, Keenan McCardell, Brian Brennan, and (for a minute each) Antonio Bryant and Andre Rison were all awfully good as well. But as good as they were, doesn’t this list just prove how limited the talent has been for the most part? I mean, Slaughter and Langhorne doesn’t exactly scream Rice and Taylor or Irvin and Harper, does it? And then there’s Braylon. I’ll get to him in another article sometime soon, but suffice it to say there is no other Brown by whom I have felt so completely and utterly let down in thirty years. He should’ve been The One.
TE: OZZIE
Duh.
LT: JOE THOMAS
I’m pretty convinced he’s the best all-around left tackle in the game today. You have to give Savage a lot of credit for doing the right thing for the franchise with the #3 pick in ’07. Too bad he didn’t follow it up by trading up for Peterson instead of Quinn (I liked it at the time. I’m just saying).
LG: ERIC STEINBACH
They’ve had some decent players, and I know Steinbach may not be around much longer because depending on who you ask, he’s either slipping generallly or just not a good fit for the Manguin’s power running attack, which demands big, road-grading guards. Steinbach is more of an athlete and technician. But that athleticism allows him to get out into blocking lanes that a lot of big men can’t get to, and to manipulate more athletic defenders when he gets there.
C: ALEX MACK
Another potentially huge move for the franchise to skip the splash pick and plug in the best center prospect I’ve seen in a decade. Mack is only going into his second NFL season, but I’ve been watching him since Cal. Love the kid, as I explained in our Center Rankings. Steve Everitt was pretty solid. LeCharles Bentley would’ve been the perfect Browns pivot. Horrendous luck.
RG: SHAUN O’HARA
Why is this guy a Giant, again? I mean, I went back over thirty years to make sure I wasn’t forgetting anybody, and it’s embarrassing how bad the Browns have been at this spot. I liked O’Hara right away. Attitude, technique, reliability. Check, check, check. He has a Super Bowl ring, and has opened holes of enormous proportion for the likes of Earth, Wind and Fire for years now.
RT: RYAN TUCKER
Tuck was an animal on the right side for a number of years. If the Browns could have peak Tucker right now, they’d have one of the top 5 offensive lines in the league, easy. It’s a shame he was wasted on a garbage team for the bulk of that time. Cody Risien was solid back in the day.
DEFENSE
DE: ROB BURNETT & CARL HAIRSTON
Burnett was nasty, and proof that Belichick has always known exactly what he was doing when it came to defensive linemen. Stout against the run and a really good pass rusher, Burnett had 28 sacks from ’92-’94, and won himself a ring in 2000 with the hated Ratbirds. Big Daddy Hairston was just a pro. Got after the quarterback well, and seemed to come up with big plays constantly. As an aside, I sure would like to have seen what Courtney Brown would have been had he not been so fragile.
DT: MICHAEL DEAN PERRY & BOB GOLIC
The MF MDP, as I call him, was the most under-appreciated NFL player of his era. He was ultra-quick off the ball, dominated the nose in the run game and was hell on quarterbacks. An upper-middle classman’s Warren Sapp. Plus, absolutely unstoppable on Tecmo Bowl, as my boy Murph can attest. Golic, meanwhile, was a tough-as-nails DT with a big personality, and later a super-understanding R.A. to Zach, Slater & Screech.
OLB: #57 & CHIP BANKS
I still compare all OLB’s to Clay Matthews, Jr. Incredible motor, and just had an innate feel for the game. His kid ain’t bad, either. Meanwhile, Marty’s trade of Chip Banks remains one of the biggest blunders in franchise history. He was as physically gifted as any man to step on an NFL field, and on his best days reminded me of Lawrence Taylor. (I said it. What?) Remember that time he sacked Bernie four times in an afternoon, leading the Colts to a shellacking of his former team? I do. Jamir Miller gets a nod here as well, as a fellow Bruin and the first Browns post-Return Pro-Bowler. Had he not gotten hurt, he could’ve bumped Banks.
ILB: EDDIE & MIKE JOHNSON
These guys were just solid pieces. Generally, they didn’t have much to work with, and their careers didn’t entirely overlap, but they fit nicely together here. I admired Andra Davis’ productivity and D’Qwell is a tackles machine, but neither is much of a playmaker. Both Johnsons were.
CB: HANFORD DIXON & FRANK MINNIFIELD
Duh x 2. The O.D.’s. (Original Dawgs)
S: ERIC TURNER & FELIX WRIGHT
Turner is one of my all-time favorite football players, period. A fellow Bruin and a stud Browns safety, there has never been a better layer of wood, bringer of hat, destroyer of middle goers-over than E-Rock. But Felix Wright was pretty damn close, and provided one of the all-time Browns highlights when he dumped Don Beebe on his head in a playoff game.
KR: JOSH CRIBBS: Mind-boggling power and explosiveness as a return man.
PR: ERIC METCALF: Mind-boggling speed and quickness as a return man.
The Ice Cube gets a solid honorable mention here, too. The Browns have certainly had their share of great returers.
K: PHIL DAWSON: The Steady Texan.
P: CHRIS GARDOCKI: I guess.
Who did I miss? Who is on your personal All-Browns Team? Check in below!